A- rating for Sulphur Springs Valley Electric Cooperative from Fitch

Source:Fitch Ratings

Fitch Ratings has assigned an initial 'A-' rating to Sulphur Springs Valley Electric Cooperative (SSVEC), AZ's implied senior secured obligations.

The SSVEC rating takes into account approximately $168 million of secured debt obligations but is implied since none of the debt is publicly held.

The Rating Outlook is Stable.


SSVEC's senior secured obligations are secured by a lien on substantially all of its assets.


ELECTRIC DISTRIBUTION COOPERATIVE: SSVEC is a non-profit, distribution cooperative providing electricity to a primarily residential customer base of approximately 52,000 in southeastern Arizona.

PARTIAL REQUIREMENTS POWER SUPPLY: Power supply is met (approximately 80%) through a long-term, partial requirements contract with the Arizona Electric Power Cooperative (AEPCO); supply needs not provided by AEPCO are purchased on the market.

IMPROVED FINANCIALS: Financial metrics improved in fiscal 2012 with debt service coverage at 1.96 times (x) and equity at 32.5%. Very low cash reserves (two days cash on hand) are supplemented by external short-term lines of credit, but total liquidity is still low for the rating.

RATE REGULATED ENTITY: SSVEC's and AEPCO's rate flexibility are somewhat limited as rates are subject to approval by the Arizona Corporation Commission (ACC). While the ACC's recent adoption of a streamlined rate process could result in a more supportive environment, Fitch views SSVEC's ability to recover costs in a full and timely manner with some concern.

ENVIRONMENTAL COST PRESSURE: Power costs may increase significantly depending on the outcome of a still unresolved dispute between AEPCO and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) over haze related emissions from its two coal units. AEPCO is appealing the ruling; the timeframe for a resolution is uncertain.

MANAGEABLE CAPITAL NEEDS: SSVEC's system-based capital needs are manageable and largely consist of distribution and sub-transmission system improvements.

MIXED SERVICE AREA: SSVEC's service area is a mix of semi-urban, rural, and agricultural areas with moderately below average income levels and below average job growth. Energy sales and peak demand have remained fairly stable over the past few years.


INCREASED COST OF POWER: An unfavorable resolution to the ongoing dispute between the EPA and AEPCO that significantly raises SSVEC's cost of power could put downward pressure on the rating unless offset, as expected, by SSVEC's wholesale power and fuel cost adjustor.


SSVEC is a not-for-profit, distribution cooperative providing electric service to a primarily residential customer base totaling 51,752 (fiscal 2012) in Southeast Arizona. SSVEC's service area includes most of Cochise County and portions of Pima, Santa Cruz, and Graham Counties.

SSVEC's customer base is primarily residential (81%), although residential customers accounted for less than half (43%) of total energy sales in fiscal 2011. A non-concentrated group of commercial and industrial customers accounted for 37% of sales with irrigation customers, consisting of the water pumping needs of agricultural interests, comprising the bulk of the remainder at 19% of sales.


Arizona is one of the few states where municipal and cooperative electric utilities, including SSVEC and its power supplying cooperatives, are subject to fiscal and operating oversight by a state regulatory commission. Fitch generally views regulatory oversight unfavorably, as state commissions add a layer of uncertainty and lag in terms of cost recovery and are a challenge not shared with most other public power entities.

SSVEC benefits from a wholesale power and fuel cost adjustor (WPFCA) that was approved by the ACC in April 2012. The WPFCA allows SSVEC to automatically pass through increases and decreases in wholesale power costs within a specified range without seeking additional ACC approval. Fitch views the WPFCA positively as it can be used to offset power cost volatility.


AEPCO provides SSVEC with power primarily from its dual-fuel capable (coal and natural gas) but principally coal-fired Steam Units 2 and 3 (ST2 and ST3) located at Apache Generation Station in Cochise County. The EPA issued a final ruling in November 2012 imposing stricter haze related emission standards on several power facilities within Arizona, including the Apache Station.

The installation of expensive selective catalytic reduction (SCR) emission control technology in combination with other emissions control equipment may be necessary to reduce emissions to the EPA required level. AEPCO appealed the EPA's decision in early February 2013. The two parties remain in negotiations with an uncertain timeframe for final resolution.

An unfavorable ruling for AEPCO and the subsequent installation of SCR and related emissions reduction equipment would likely lead to a significant increase in AEPCO's wholesale power rate that would pressure SSVEC's financial performance without a commensurate increase in retail rates.


SSVEC's financial metrics improved in recent years due to increased energy sales and higher rates effective for partial fiscal year 2010 (full fiscal year 2011). Fitch calculated debt service coverage improved to 1.84x and 1.96x in fiscals 2011 and 2012, respectively, from a low of 1.27x in fiscal 2009. Equity as a percentage of capitalization increased incrementally in fiscal 2012 to 32.5% from 28.4% in fiscal 2009.

SSVEC's cash position is very low with only two days cash on hand at the end of fiscal 2012, which is a significant concern. Maintaining minimal cash reserves and using lines of credit to meet working capital needs have been part of management's strategy to keep rates as low as possible. However, relying on external sources of credit, as opposed to holding sufficient cash on hand, as the primary source of liquidity presents greater risk. SSVEC's line of credit for fiscal 2013 amounts to $17.6 million, leaving liquidity at a still low 76 days.

Additional information is available at 'www.fitchratings.com'. The ratings above were solicited by, or on behalf of, the issuer, and therefore, Fitch has been compensated for the provision of the ratings.

In addition to the sources of information identified in Fitch's Revenue-Supported Rating Criteria and U.S. Public Power Rating Criteria, this action was informed by information from CreditScope.

Did You Like this Article? Get All the Energy Industry News Delivered to Your Inbox

Subscribe to an email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest news and information.

 Subscribe Now


The Time is Right for Optimum Reliability: Capital-Intensive Industries and Asset Performance Management

Imagine a plant that is no longer at risk of a random shutdown. Imagine not worrying about losing...

Going Digital: The New Normal in Oil & Gas

In this whitepaper you will learn how Keystone Engineering, ONGC, and Saipem are using software t...

Maximizing Operational Excellence

In a recent survey conducted by PennEnergy Research, 70% of surveyed energy industry professional...

Leveraging the Power of Information in the Energy Industry

Information Governance is about more than compliance. It’s about using your information to drive ...

Latest PennEnergy Jobs

PennEnergy Oil & Gas Jobs