EPSA worries about impact of state CO2 plans on interstate markets

The Clean Power Plan

As a representative for competitive generators, Electric Power Supply Association (EPSA) President and CEO John Shelk likes to say that his organization is “fuel neutral,” meaning that it does not play favorites among fuel sources for electric power.

"We did not comment on all the soup-to-nuts issues," connected with the Clean Power Plan proposed by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Shelk said Dec. 8 during the PennWell GenForum conference in Orlando, Fla.

Nevertheless, EPSA does have some concerns with the EPA plan, Shelk told the gathering organized by


EPSA members are deeply engaged in interstate power markets. As a result, the group is worried about the structure of the EPA proposal that instructs states to draft plans to cut CO2 emissions 30% by 2030.

"How does the EPA plan continue to allow wholesale markets to continue to market, or not," Shelk said. "There are interstate markets," he said.

"You really have to work with FERC and the states." You cannot dispatch the grid "state by state," Shelk said.

The EPSA official said that the EPA CO2 proposal is different from prior pollutant rules that sometimes involved state implementation. "We are not putting a gizmo or a gadget on a plant" to control CO2, Shelk said. The EPA rule is addressing things like energy efficiency and dispatch rates for certain types of plants, Shelk said.

At the same time, Shelk stressed that his members, which include the likes of Calpine (NYSE:CPN), Exelon (NYSE:EXC) and NRG Energy (NYSE:NRG) don't necessarily oppose a federal carbon regime.

"A lot of our members like the EPA plan," Shelk said. "We are not in the climate denier camp," he added.

Competitive suppliers are different from regulated utilities in that they don't have a rate base to cushion the impact of increased expenses. "You feel the bumps in the road quicker and with more force," in competitive power, Shelk said. For example, the cheap natural gas prices were felt first and most by competitive suppliers.

The EPSA website currently lists 15 members. Shelk said that while his organization has fewer members than it did a few years back it controls more generation capacity, thanks to industry consolidation.

EPSA looking at FERC, legal, regulatory issues





During the past year, courts have often been deciding where the lines are drawn between federal and state jurisdiction







of energy markets, Shelk said.





The New Jersey and Maryland state generation subsidy programs were shot down by federal appeals courts. Maryland has asked for U.S. Supreme Court review. Shelk, an attorney, doubts the high court will hear the case given that there was no split among federal circuits.

The Maryland and New Jersey cases are examples where “everybody wanted the bright new shiny plant," and the jobs that come with them, Shelk said. “Today's new plant is tomorrow's old plant," Shelk said. It was an attempt "to force feed the system" although there were already ample supplies of power, he added.

There seem to be constant efforts at the state level to second-guess competition, Shelk said.

Nationally, there will be a “change in the gavel” at the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) in 2015, Shelk noted. In April Norman Bay will succeed Cheryl LaFleur as chairman of FERC. Bay was confirmed to FERC by the Senate last summer. Under a deal worked out by lawmakers, he will succeed LaFleur as chair in 2015. LaFleur has been leading FERC since she was named acting chairman in November 2013.

Shelk also said he was happy to see the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee approve Colette D. Honorable of the Arkansas Public Service Commission to fill the final FERC vacancy.

Shelk also noted that EPSA is monitoring the so-called "fuel assurance" rule at FERC. Regional Transmission Organizations (RTOs) have until mid-February to submit reports on what they are doing to blunt the impact of a future polar vortex, he noted.

Meanwhile, EPSA continues to be engaged in legal follow-up to a demand response ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. In May by a three-judge panel for the D.C. Circuit ruled two-to-one that a FERC rule concerning demand side management should be vacated “in its entirety.”

FERC will be allowed to go ahead and seek Supreme Court review, Shelk said.

A "sleeper case" is D.C. Circuit case concerns EPA exempting demand response units from certain EPA rules, Shelk said. The case involves application of some EPA standards to so-called “behind-the-meter” generation.

Shelk says companies keep backup generators for many reasons. EPSA argued this setup was being abused by some to get around tough EPA standards. "You are just shifting your demand to these diesel generators," Shelk said.

This is not fair to conventional power plants that are fully regulated by EPA, EPSA has argued.

This article was republished with permission from





2014 Articles

Harvard Law School professor pays Clean Power Plan is unconstitutional


Laurence H. Tribe, professor of constitutional law at Harvard University and former mentor to Barack Obama, said in an article last week that the EPA’s Clean Power Plan is unconstitutional.

3 SKorea workers die at nuke plant construction site


SEOUL, South Korea (AP) — Three South Korean workers died Friday after apparently inhaling toxic gas at a construction site for a nuclear plant being built by South Korea's monopoly nuclear power company, which has come un...

UMaine in business of certifying turbine blades


ORONO, Maine (AP) — The University of Maine has tested its largest wind turbine blade to date. UMaine's Advanced Structures and Composites Center completed static strength testing this month of a 184-foot-long wind turbine...

Mergers, EPA carbon plan generated much attention during 2014


Mergers, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Clean Power Plan, cheap natural gas and the polar vortex were among the most noteworthy generation stories of 2014.

Developer opens Ohio review for 800-MW, gas-fired project


Clean Energy Future-Lordstown LLC plans an 800-MW, gas-fired power project, and on Dec. 24 applied with the Ohio Power Siting Board for certain routine waivers it needs before filing a full siting application for this proj...

New England utility exec named to Vermont PSB


A woman who worked for Vermont's Department of Public Service for 17 years is going to become the next member of the utility-regulating Public Service Board. The appointment of Sarah Hofmann was announced Monday by Gov. Pe...

Brown picks aide to lead troubled California utility board


Gov. Jerry Brown named a former adviser on Tuesday to be the next head of California's troubled utilities commission, replacing a regulatory chief accused of back-channel dealings with utilities. Michael Picker, a former a...

Washington state carbon emissions dropped in 2011


Greenhouse gas emissions in Washington state dropped by about 4.6 percent between 2010 and 2011, led by reductions in emissions from the electricity sector, according to the latest figures released by the state. The latest...

Group wants state regulators recused from PNM case


State regulators in less than two weeks are to begin deliberating a proposal that calls for shutting down part of an aging coal-fired power plant in northwestern New Mexico that serves more than 2 million customers in the ...

Vermont Yankee plant prepares to shut down


The Vermont Yankee nuclear plant is getting ready to shut down. Its owner, Entergy Corp., says it is closing the plant for economic reasons. The plant in Vernon is expected to disconnect from the regional power grid Monday.

PSEG Solar to acquire Maryland solar project from juwi


PSEG Solar Source will acquire a 12.9-MW solar energy facility near Waldorf, Maryland from juwi solar (JSI). The PSEG Waldorf Solar Energy Center will increase the capacity of PSEG Solar Source's portfolio to 123-MW.

PG&E discloses more emails with state regulators


California's largest power utility released a dozen more emails Monday that it said showed improper back-channel discussions between the utility and top state regulators.

Indianapolis airport solar farm expansion completed


Contractors have finished bringing online dozens of acres of solar panels at Indianapolis International Airport, solidifying its status as the home of the nation's largest airport-based solar farm.

French power company to pay $772M in bribery case


A French power and transportation company has agreed to pay $772 million to resolve allegations that it bribed high-ranking foreign government officials for lucrative projects, the Justice Department said Monday.

Nebraska nuclear plant back online after short outage


The Fort Calhoun nuclear power plant is back online less than a week after its main generator unexpectedly shut down as a precaution.

Ameren Missouri plans $135M in energy efficiency


Missouri's largest electric company said Monday that it plans to invest $135 million in energy efficiency programs for customers over a three-year period.

TEPCO completes nuclear fuel assemblies removal from Fukushima 4


Tokyo Electric Power Co. (TEPCO) said it has safely removed the fuel assemblies from the most damaged nuclear reactor at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant.

B&W Vølund to build waste-to-energy power plant in Scotland


In a consortium with Interserve, Babcock & Wilcox Co.’s (B&W, NYSE:BWC) subsidiary, Babcock & Wilcox Vølund A/S (B&W Vølund), will engineer, procure and construct (EPC) a waste-to-energy (WTE) power plant f...

SKorea holds N-plant drills against cyber threats


South Korea's monopoly nuclear power company said it began drills Monday against possible cyberattacks after online threats of attack against its plants.

PSC approves solar power project


The Public Service Commission has approved solar power project planned by Kentucky Utilities and Louisville Gas and Electric in Mercer County.

Did You Like this Article? Get All the Energy Industry News Delivered to Your Inbox

Subscribe to an email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest news and information.

 Subscribe Now


Logistics Risk Management in the Transformer Industry

Transformers often are shipped thousands of miles, involving multiple handoffs,and more than a do...

Secrets of Barco UniSee Mount Revealed

Last year Barco introduced UniSee, a revolutionary large-scale visualization platform designed to...

The Time is Right for Optimum Reliability: Capital-Intensive Industries and Asset Performance Management

Imagine a plant that is no longer at risk of a random shutdown. Imagine not worrying about losing...

Going Digital: The New Normal in Oil & Gas

In this whitepaper you will learn how Keystone Engineering, ONGC, and Saipem are using software t...