Holmstead sees EPA CO2 plan being overturned; Tierney hails potential for regional cooperation

GenerationHub Wayne Barber Bracewell & Giuliani Jeffrey Holmstead Analysis Group Susan Tierney Environmental Protection Agency EPA CO2 carbon dioxide

 

Power industry lawyer Jeffrey Holmstead believes the plans that the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has forwarded to reduce carbon dioxide from the power sector are legally flawed an likely to be overturned in the courts.

During a June 18 appearance before the Bipartisan Policy Center in Washington, D.C., Holmstead said there was an 80% chance that either the EPA CO2 proposal for new plants or the just-issued proposed rule for existing plants will be overturned.

Holmstead served as EPA's assistant administrator for air and radiation during the George W. Bush administration. He now heads the environmental strategies group at the Bracewell & Giuliani firm in Washington, D.C.

Susan Tierney, a senior advisor at the Analysis Group, declined to debate the legal aspects of the proposed rules but said she is bullish on the EPA proposals from an economic and public policy perspective.

Tierney is a former assistant secretary for policy at the Department of Energy (DOE) in the Clinton administration, and a former state energy official in Massachusetts. She also chairs an advisory board of the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, and is a director of the World Resources Institute.

Tierney considers the EPA proposal seeking a 30% CO2 reduction below 2005 levels by 2030 “reasonably ambitious” and flexible enough to allow “every state to take some action.”

In particular, Tierney thinks EPA has done a good job of providing enough flexibility for states to pursue regional solutions, such as cap-and-trade organizations like the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) in the Northeast.

The EPA program could create a scenario where New Jersey might consider rejoining RGGI and Pennsylvania might consider joining the group as well, Tierney said.

Tierney also believes there could be the potential for regional cooperation among utility holding companies in the Southeast who do business in multiple states.

Holmstead says EPA clearly overstepping its bounds

“As someone who believes in the rule of law, I think this clearly goes beyond what EPA is allowed to do under the Clean Air Act,” Holmstead said. EPA seems to think it can regulate the electric utility industry in every state and that is “pretty far-fetched.”

In many states it will be the state utility commission, rather than the state environmental regulators, who would be responsible for carrying out the EPA mandate, Holmstead said. In some cases, new state legislation might have to be passed to enable full implementation of the EPA cuts.

Technically, EPA can step in and take over if a suitable state implementation plan, or SIP, is not submitted. That could prove difficult in reality, Holmstead said.

“This is not the first time this has ever happened,” Tierney countered. The EPA has already had states draft SIPs for ozone, she said.

“The politics of this are quite different than the politics of ozone,” Holmstead said. The industry attorney also said that in past litigation over EPA mercury rules, some environmental groups argued in favor of uniform compliance standards for all power plants - and that's not the case here, Holmstead said.

Tierney, however, believes that one reason EPA has given states the leeway to try a number of approaches is that EPA wants to rely predominantly on existing technology options.

It is important for the United States to take a leadership role on climate change because one ton out of every 15 tons of CO2 emitted globally come from the U.S. electric power sector, Tierney said.

When asked, Holmstead said the proposed EPA CO2 regime does not do enough to encourage carbon capture and storage (CCS) without heavy government subsidization.

Holmstead also said that heavy manufacturing states like Texas will face a tough time under the proposed EPA rule for existing plants. It appears that nearly 20% of all power generation CO2 cuts will have to come from Texas, Holmstead said.

One issue that Holmstead and Tierney did agree is that the current version of the EPA rule for existing plants does not sufficiently credit power companies for taking early action before 2020.

There was also one other issue that Holmstead and Tierney agreed upon. Both said that regardless of what happens with the current EPA CO2 proposals that Congress is likely to pass some type of CO2 bill within the next decade. They also believe that some of type of international CO2 agreement is apt to be reached in the next 10 years.

“They will not be exactly what people envision today,” Holmstead said.

Holmstead will be speaking at the PennWell GenForum conference Aug. 19 in Nashville. A webcast of the June 18 discussion involving Holmstead and Tierney can be found at the Bipartisan Policy Center website: http://bipartisanpolicy.org/events/2014/06/discussing-epa%E2%80%99s-newly-released-clean-power-plan

This article was republished with permission from GenerationHub.

2014 Articles

EPA’s Clean Power Plan will rise energy prices

11/21/2014 The cost of electricity and natural gas will increase by nearly $300 billion in 2020 compared to 2012 prices, according to the “Energy Market Impacts of Recent Federal Regulations on the Electric Power Sector,” report cond...

Regulators OK more time to build nuclear fuel plant

11/21/2014

Federal regulators have granted a 10-year extension to the company building a South Carolina facility where spent nuclear weapons materials will be turned into commercial nuclear reactor fuel.

GDF Suez purchases battery system from Eos Energy Storage

11/21/2014 GDF SUEZ has purchased Eos Energy Storage’s zinc hybrid cathode battery energy storage system. The sale marks the next phase in Eos’s pilot demonstration program, after 3rd-party testing with DNV GL.

EU residential energy prices climbing faster than US

11/21/2014

European residential electricity prices have significantly exceeded U.S. prices, and the gap has widened in recent years.

Plan divides billions in closed nuke plant costs

11/21/2014

California regulators have approved a settlement to divide billions of dollars in costs from the closed San Onofre nuclear power plant.

Bechtel, Siemens, Panda Power Funds dedicate Sherman Power Project in Texas

11/20/2014

Panda Power Funds, Siemens (NYSE: SI) and Bechtel dedicated the 758-MW Panda Sherman Power Project in Sherman, Texas, two weeks ahead of schedule.

Siemens to supply H-Class gas turbines to Japan power plant

11/20/2014 Siemens (NYSE: SI) has received its first order from Japan to deliver two, 400-MW SGT5-8000H gas turbines along with the associated auxiliary systems to form the core of the combined-cycle power plant of Kobe Steel, Ltd. (...

Shining a Light on Women Leaders in the Power Industry

11/20/2014

Meet the three finalists for the POWER-GEN 2014 Women of the Year Award, the winner of which will be announced next month.

Cold weather continues to exert pressure on Eastern spot gas, power prices

11/20/2014

Unseasonably cold air continues to bring frigid temperatures and snow in many parts of the northern United States, and it also continues to exert pressure on spot energy prices.

NRG protests move by New York PSC toward Ginna life extension

11/20/2014 Subsidiaries of NRG Energy (NYSE: NRG) told the New York State Public Service Commission on Nov. 17 that they are disappointed with a commission order that advances a plan to keep open the uneconomic R.E. Ginna nuclear pla...

GE installs 25,000th wind turbine

11/19/2014 GE (NYSE: GE) has successfully installed its 25,000th wind turbine, bringing its wind power capacity to more than 38-GW.

ACCIONA Windpower to supply capacity for IKEA’s largest renewable energy project

11/19/2014 ACCIONA Windpower has entered into a contract with Apex Clean Energy, to supply 55  AW125/3000 turbines to the 165-MW Cameron Wind farm, owned by the IKEA Group. The agreement includes a 20-year full service warranty.

NRG Energy opens offices in California, focuses on residential solar

11/19/2014 NRG Home Solar, a subsidiary of NRG Energy (NYSE: NRG), is opening two California offices in Merced and San Diego. The expansion creates more than 100 job opportunities.

EPA asks 4th Circuit not to transfer Cooling Water Intake Rule review

11/19/2014 On Monday, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and power industry groups asked the Fourth Circuit to not transfer petitions to review EPA's cooling water intake rule to the Second Circuit, as Riverkeeper Inc. an...

NRC chair: Work needed to finish Fukushima changes

11/19/2014 The outgoing chair of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission said Tuesday the industry must finish making the safety changes required after a nuclear disaster in Japan, and it faces unresolved questions over how to store n...

EPA asks DC Circuit to reject challenge to boiler rule

11/18/2014

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has urged the D.C. Circuit to reject a challenge to a rule that establishes toxic emission standards for large boilers.

Northwestern Energy finalizes acquisition of PPL Montana’s hydroelectric facilities

11/18/2014

NorthWestern Energy (NYSE: NWE) has closed on a $900 million purchase of 11 hydroelectric facilities representing 633-MW of capacity and one storage reservoir from PPL Montana (NYSE: PPL).

Canadian Solar supplies PV modules for Georgia solar power projects

11/18/2014 Canadian Solar Inc. will supply its CS6X-310-P photovoltaic (PV) modules to a series of projects in Georgia totaling 5.1-MW with SolAmerica Energy LLC.

Solar energy co. SunEdison buying wind power co.

11/18/2014 Solar energy company SunEdison is adding some wind-fueled power to its business with a deal worth up to $2.4 billion.

Huge US solar plant lags in early production

11/18/2014

The largest solar power plant of its type in the world - once promoted as a turning point in green energy - isn't producing as much energy as planned.

Whitepapers

Energize Your Most Vital Business Relationships: Advanced Contract Lifecycle Management in the Oil and Gas Sector

In today’s more dynamic and globalized energy marketplace, formal contracts define nearly every b...

Improve Accuracy and Reduce your Lease Operating Expense and Risk in Upstream Oil & Gas Production

In this whitepaper, we will address both the technical approach to achieving the highest possible...

Infographic: Smart Process Applications for a Mobile Workforce

In partnership with PennEnergy Research, OpenText surveyed energy companies in the oil and gas, p...

Survey Report: Smart Process Applications for a Mobile Workforce

In partnership with PennEnergy Research, OpenText surveyed energy companies in the oil and gas, p...