Holmstead sees EPA CO2 plan being overturned; Tierney hails potential for regional cooperation

GenerationHub Wayne Barber Bracewell & Giuliani Jeffrey Holmstead Analysis Group Susan Tierney Environmental Protection Agency EPA CO2 carbon dioxide


Power industry lawyer Jeffrey Holmstead believes the plans that the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has forwarded to reduce carbon dioxide from the power sector are legally flawed an likely to be overturned in the courts.

During a June 18 appearance before the Bipartisan Policy Center in Washington, D.C., Holmstead said there was an 80% chance that either the EPA CO2 proposal for new plants or the just-issued proposed rule for existing plants will be overturned.

Holmstead served as EPA's assistant administrator for air and radiation during the George W. Bush administration. He now heads the environmental strategies group at the Bracewell & Giuliani firm in Washington, D.C.

Susan Tierney, a senior advisor at the Analysis Group, declined to debate the legal aspects of the proposed rules but said she is bullish on the EPA proposals from an economic and public policy perspective.

Tierney is a former assistant secretary for policy at the Department of Energy (DOE) in the Clinton administration, and a former state energy official in Massachusetts. She also chairs an advisory board of the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, and is a director of the World Resources Institute.

Tierney considers the EPA proposal seeking a 30% CO2 reduction below 2005 levels by 2030 “reasonably ambitious” and flexible enough to allow “every state to take some action.”

In particular, Tierney thinks EPA has done a good job of providing enough flexibility for states to pursue regional solutions, such as cap-and-trade organizations like the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) in the Northeast.

The EPA program could create a scenario where New Jersey might consider rejoining RGGI and Pennsylvania might consider joining the group as well, Tierney said.

Tierney also believes there could be the potential for regional cooperation among utility holding companies in the Southeast who do business in multiple states.

Holmstead says EPA clearly overstepping its bounds

“As someone who believes in the rule of law, I think this clearly goes beyond what EPA is allowed to do under the Clean Air Act,” Holmstead said. EPA seems to think it can regulate the electric utility industry in every state and that is “pretty far-fetched.”

In many states it will be the state utility commission, rather than the state environmental regulators, who would be responsible for carrying out the EPA mandate, Holmstead said. In some cases, new state legislation might have to be passed to enable full implementation of the EPA cuts.

Technically, EPA can step in and take over if a suitable state implementation plan, or SIP, is not submitted. That could prove difficult in reality, Holmstead said.

“This is not the first time this has ever happened,” Tierney countered. The EPA has already had states draft SIPs for ozone, she said.

“The politics of this are quite different than the politics of ozone,” Holmstead said. The industry attorney also said that in past litigation over EPA mercury rules, some environmental groups argued in favor of uniform compliance standards for all power plants - and that's not the case here, Holmstead said.

Tierney, however, believes that one reason EPA has given states the leeway to try a number of approaches is that EPA wants to rely predominantly on existing technology options.

It is important for the United States to take a leadership role on climate change because one ton out of every 15 tons of CO2 emitted globally come from the U.S. electric power sector, Tierney said.

When asked, Holmstead said the proposed EPA CO2 regime does not do enough to encourage carbon capture and storage (CCS) without heavy government subsidization.

Holmstead also said that heavy manufacturing states like Texas will face a tough time under the proposed EPA rule for existing plants. It appears that nearly 20% of all power generation CO2 cuts will have to come from Texas, Holmstead said.

One issue that Holmstead and Tierney did agree is that the current version of the EPA rule for existing plants does not sufficiently credit power companies for taking early action before 2020.

There was also one other issue that Holmstead and Tierney agreed upon. Both said that regardless of what happens with the current EPA CO2 proposals that Congress is likely to pass some type of CO2 bill within the next decade. They also believe that some of type of international CO2 agreement is apt to be reached in the next 10 years.

“They will not be exactly what people envision today,” Holmstead said.

Holmstead will be speaking at the PennWell GenForum conference Aug. 19 in Nashville. A webcast of the June 18 discussion involving Holmstead and Tierney can be found at the Bipartisan Policy Center website: http://bipartisanpolicy.org/events/2014/06/discussing-epa%E2%80%99s-newly-released-clean-power-plan

This article was republished with permission from GenerationHub.

2014 Articles

B&W previews Florida waste-to-energy facility for Congressman

08/29/2014 The Babcock & Wilcox Co. (B&W, NYSE: BWC) hosted Congressman Patrick Murphy (D-FL-18) for a preview of the Solid Waste Authority of Palm Beach County Renewable Energy Park.

Fluor completes 170 MW solar energy facility in California


Fluor Corp. (NYSE: FLR) has completed the engineering, procurement, construction and commissioning for LS Power’s Centinela Solar Energy Facility located near El Centro, California.

Chint Power Systems America provides solar power to Texas homeless shelter


Chint Power Systems America is providing solar power for the non-profit organization, Wichita Falls Faith Mission Inc., on behalf of its shelter for women and children in Wichita Falls, Texas.

DOE settles used nuclear fuel storage lawsuit for $23.5mn


Energy Northwest (EN) won a $23.5 million settlement from the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) for the construction and licensing of a used nuclear fuel storage area at the Columbia Generating Station in Washington.

SunEdison, TerraForm Power bring solar energy to California prison, hospital

08/29/2014 SunEdison Inc. (NYSE: SUNE) and TerraForm Power have completed the 2.6-MW solar power system at the Coalinga State Hospital and a 1.6-MW solar system at the Pleasant Valley State Prison in California.

NextEra withdraws, at least for now, from Energy Future case

08/29/2014 NextEra Energy (NYSE: NEE) told the bankruptcy court for Energy Future Holdings on Aug. 26 that it is withdrawing a July “strategic” reorganization plan that it had offered in cooperation with Energy Future Holdings.

TVA Browns Ferry 1 knocked offline


The Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) Browns Ferry 1 nuclear unit in Alabama experienced a turbine trip and went offline during the evening of Aug. 26.

GE opens fuel cell facility in New York


General Electric Co. is opening a new facility north of Albany devoted to the development of fuel cells.

08/27 Henry Hub Average Natural Gas Spot Prices


The Henry Hub is the pricing point for natural gas futures contracts traded on the New York Mercantile Exchange (NYMEX).

First nuclear reactor in UAE more than halfway complete


The first nuclear reactor being built in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) is now more than halfway finished.

NRC says no safety issues to impede nuclear power plant license renewal


The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) said there are no technical issues to stop the license renewal for the Callaway nuclear power plant in Missouri.

Duke Energy to retire W.C. Beckjord Station coal-fired units


Duke Energy (NYSE: DUK) announced Thursday that the company will retire the remaining coal-fired units, 5 and 6, at its W.C. Beckjord Station in New Richmond, Ohio, effective Sept. 1.

Weekly Coal Production


The Weekly Coal Production Report has been updated for the week ended August 23, 2014.

Xcel Energy defends $665mn Monticello plant project


Xcel Energy says customers should pay for the overrun costs of a $665 million project to rebuild a power plant in Monticello.

US fund in deal to build Myanmar solar plants


A U.S investment fund has signed a $480 million deal to build two solar energy plants in central Myanmar, one of the largest investments by an American firm since the easing of U.S. sanctions.

Kudankulam nuclear unit may begin commercial operations next month

08/28/2014 The Nuclear Power Corporation of India (NPCIL) expects to begin commercial operations of the first unit at the Kudankulam Nuclear Power Project in September.

Westinghouse contests S. Africa nuclear steam generator replacement contract


Westinghouse Electric Co. filed an interdict to reopen a bidding process for a contract awarded to Areva for a steam generator replacement project at a nuclear power plant in South Africa.

Pacific Nuclear Council names two new officers


The Pacific Nuclear Council (PNC) announced its new officers for 2014-2016 during the organization’s 19th bi-annual international gathering in British Columbia, Canada.

Westinghouse to replace nuclear fuel at Oskarshamn power plant


Westinghouse Electric Co. will provide replacement nuclear fuel deliveries for three units at the Oskarshamn nuclear power plant in Sweden.

Minnesota Power, National Guard to build 10 MW solar energy project


Minnesota Power, a subsidiary of ALLETE Inc., (NYSE:ALE), and the Minnesota National Guard will join forces to build a 10-MW solar power project at Camp Ripley.


Survey Report: Smart Process Applications for a Mobile Workforce

In partnership with PennEnergy Research, OpenText surveyed energy companies in the oil and gas, p...

Top 20 Controls ICS Implementation Guide

Considering the complexity and scope of today’s critical control environment, compliance has beco...

Five Steps to Build an Effective Threat Intelligence Capability

Against today’s mutating threat landscape and sophisticated cybercriminals, security and risk (S&...

Big Data: Business Insight for Power and Utilities

With this paper Microsoft aims to distill the Big Data drivers, challenges, and opportunities for...