Holmstead sees EPA CO2 plan being overturned; Tierney hails potential for regional cooperation

GenerationHub Wayne Barber Bracewell & Giuliani Jeffrey Holmstead Analysis Group Susan Tierney Environmental Protection Agency EPA CO2 carbon dioxide

 

Power industry lawyer Jeffrey Holmstead believes the plans that the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has forwarded to reduce carbon dioxide from the power sector are legally flawed an likely to be overturned in the courts.

During a June 18 appearance before the Bipartisan Policy Center in Washington, D.C., Holmstead said there was an 80% chance that either the EPA CO2 proposal for new plants or the just-issued proposed rule for existing plants will be overturned.

Holmstead served as EPA's assistant administrator for air and radiation during the George W. Bush administration. He now heads the environmental strategies group at the Bracewell & Giuliani firm in Washington, D.C.

Susan Tierney, a senior advisor at the Analysis Group, declined to debate the legal aspects of the proposed rules but said she is bullish on the EPA proposals from an economic and public policy perspective.

Tierney is a former assistant secretary for policy at the Department of Energy (DOE) in the Clinton administration, and a former state energy official in Massachusetts. She also chairs an advisory board of the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, and is a director of the World Resources Institute.

Tierney considers the EPA proposal seeking a 30% CO2 reduction below 2005 levels by 2030 “reasonably ambitious” and flexible enough to allow “every state to take some action.”

In particular, Tierney thinks EPA has done a good job of providing enough flexibility for states to pursue regional solutions, such as cap-and-trade organizations like the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) in the Northeast.

The EPA program could create a scenario where New Jersey might consider rejoining RGGI and Pennsylvania might consider joining the group as well, Tierney said.

Tierney also believes there could be the potential for regional cooperation among utility holding companies in the Southeast who do business in multiple states.

Holmstead says EPA clearly overstepping its bounds

“As someone who believes in the rule of law, I think this clearly goes beyond what EPA is allowed to do under the Clean Air Act,” Holmstead said. EPA seems to think it can regulate the electric utility industry in every state and that is “pretty far-fetched.”

In many states it will be the state utility commission, rather than the state environmental regulators, who would be responsible for carrying out the EPA mandate, Holmstead said. In some cases, new state legislation might have to be passed to enable full implementation of the EPA cuts.

Technically, EPA can step in and take over if a suitable state implementation plan, or SIP, is not submitted. That could prove difficult in reality, Holmstead said.

“This is not the first time this has ever happened,” Tierney countered. The EPA has already had states draft SIPs for ozone, she said.

“The politics of this are quite different than the politics of ozone,” Holmstead said. The industry attorney also said that in past litigation over EPA mercury rules, some environmental groups argued in favor of uniform compliance standards for all power plants - and that's not the case here, Holmstead said.

Tierney, however, believes that one reason EPA has given states the leeway to try a number of approaches is that EPA wants to rely predominantly on existing technology options.

It is important for the United States to take a leadership role on climate change because one ton out of every 15 tons of CO2 emitted globally come from the U.S. electric power sector, Tierney said.

When asked, Holmstead said the proposed EPA CO2 regime does not do enough to encourage carbon capture and storage (CCS) without heavy government subsidization.

Holmstead also said that heavy manufacturing states like Texas will face a tough time under the proposed EPA rule for existing plants. It appears that nearly 20% of all power generation CO2 cuts will have to come from Texas, Holmstead said.

One issue that Holmstead and Tierney did agree is that the current version of the EPA rule for existing plants does not sufficiently credit power companies for taking early action before 2020.

There was also one other issue that Holmstead and Tierney agreed upon. Both said that regardless of what happens with the current EPA CO2 proposals that Congress is likely to pass some type of CO2 bill within the next decade. They also believe that some of type of international CO2 agreement is apt to be reached in the next 10 years.

“They will not be exactly what people envision today,” Holmstead said.

Holmstead will be speaking at the PennWell GenForum conference Aug. 19 in Nashville. A webcast of the June 18 discussion involving Holmstead and Tierney can be found at the Bipartisan Policy Center website: http://bipartisanpolicy.org/events/2014/06/discussing-epa%E2%80%99s-newly-released-clean-power-plan

This article was republished with permission from GenerationHub.

2014 Articles

B&W Vølund to build waste-to-energy power plant in Scotland

12/22/2014 In a consortium with Interserve, Babcock & Wilcox Co.’s (B&W, NYSE:BWC) subsidiary, Babcock & Wilcox Vølund A/S (B&W Vølund), will engineer, procure and construct (EPC) a waste-to-energy (WTE) power plant f...

SKorea holds N-plant drills against cyber threats

12/22/2014

South Korea's monopoly nuclear power company said it began drills Monday against possible cyberattacks after online threats of attack against its plants.

PSC approves solar power project

12/22/2014

The Public Service Commission has approved solar power project planned by Kentucky Utilities and Louisville Gas and Electric in Mercer County.

Rockwood nears permit for up to 915-MW power plant in Texas

12/22/2014

The Texas Commission on Environmental Quality on Dec. 18 issued notice of a planned approval of air permitting for a gas-fired power project of Rockwood Energy Center LLC.

NRC report notes significant oil leak into Lake Michigan from AEP Cook plant

12/22/2014 An American Electric Power (NYSE:AEP) subsidiary has informed the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) that roughly 2,000 gallons of oil has leaked into Lake Michigan since late October from the D.C. Cook nuclear power stat...

Nuclear plant predicts $1.24B decommissioning cost

12/22/2014

The Vermont Yankee nuclear plant has made formal its prediction that decommissioning the reactor will cost $1.24 billion.

DTE Electric files rate increase

12/22/2014 DTE Electric, a subsidiary of DTE Energy (NYSE: DTE), has filed its first electric residential rate increase in four years. However, due to previously-planned rate adjustments, commercial and industrial consumers will see ...

EPA Admin: Coal ash considered as garbage, not hazardous waste

12/19/2014 The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Administrator Gina McCarthy announced the agency will now consider coal ash on the same level as household waste as opposed to hazardous waste. Household garbage and coal ash ...

Fuel Tech receives air pollution control contracts worth $3.6Mn

12/19/2014

Fuel Tech Inc. has received multiple air pollution control (APC) contracts, worth approximately $3.6 million, from customers in China, Europe and the U.S.

NRC: DOE’s Yucca Mountain R&D meet NRC requirements

12/19/2014

The staff of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) published Volume 4 of its safety evaluation report on a proposed underground used nuclear fuel repository in Nevada.

Video: Duke Energy acquires Halifax Solar Project in North Carolina

12/19/2014

Duke Energy Renewables (NYSE: DUK) has acquired a 20-MW solar project in Roanoke Rapids, North Carolina, from Geenex and ET Solar Energy Corp.

Westinghouse continues to provide nuclear fuel to French power plants

12/19/2014

Westinghouse Electric Co. and EDF signed a new long-term nuclear fuel contract to support EDF’s nuclear power plants in France.

Susquehanna nuclear unit 1 returned to service after leak found

12/19/2014

Workers at PPL’s (NYSE: PPL) Susquehanna nuclear power plant reconnected Unit 1 to the grid after repairing a small leak inside the containment structure.

EPA expected to treat coal ash waste like garbage

12/19/2014

Environmentalists and industry experts widely expect the first federal standards for the waste generated from coal burned for electricity to treat the ash like household garbage, rather than a hazardous material.

Land, water rights needed for Nevada nuclear dump

12/19/2014 The federal Energy Department will need to acquire water and land rights before it gets approval to entomb the nation's most radioactive waste beneath a mountain in the Nevada desert, according to a report released Thursda...

NRC delays approval of Callaway's license renewal

12/19/2014 Federal officials are delaying a decision on issuing a 20-year extension for the Callaway County nuclear power plant.

Duke Energy completes ash excavation at W.S. Lee Steam Station

12/19/2014 Duke Energy (NYSE: DUK) has submitted filings, to state regulators, outlining additional ash excavation plans for its W.S. Lee Steam Station in Belton, South Carolina.

Some see gas as replacement for Vermont Yankee

12/19/2014 About to lose their biggest employer and taxpayer with the closing of the Vermont Yankee nuclear plant, local leaders in Vernon are hoping a gas-fired power plant will be built to replace it.

Check out these highlights during Power Generation Week

12/18/2014 More than 22,000 industry professionals from around the world gathered in Orlando for Power Generation Week, where innovative and cost-effective solutions for maintaining, operating and building new power generation were s...

Westinghouse to provide nuclear decommissioning equipment to Sellafield

12/18/2014

Westinghouse Electric Co. signed a contract to deliver a second skip handler machine for the a storage pond undergoing decommissioning at the Sellafield nuclear site in the UK.

Whitepapers

Energize Your Most Vital Business Relationships: Advanced Contract Lifecycle Management in the Oil and Gas Sector

In today’s more dynamic and globalized energy marketplace, formal contracts define nearly every b...

Improve Accuracy and Reduce your Lease Operating Expense and Risk in Upstream Oil & Gas Production

In this whitepaper, we will address both the technical approach to achieving the highest possible...

Infographic: Smart Process Applications for a Mobile Workforce

In partnership with PennEnergy Research, OpenText surveyed energy companies in the oil and gas, p...

Survey Report: Smart Process Applications for a Mobile Workforce

In partnership with PennEnergy Research, OpenText surveyed energy companies in the oil and gas, p...